How to sell
Alcohol & Recovery
Online
In this case study, we'll unpack how Lull Mattress achieved a 100% transaction increase and 61% ARPU boost by testing three radically different brand narratives instead of optimizing one mediocre message. More importantly, you'll discover how to escape the positioning trap that kills conversion rates in competitive markets: assuming you know which story resonates before you test it. These strategies will show you how to find your winning narrative through systematic experimentation, not gut feelings or competitor copying.
Market Research
For context, we're a team of top strategists, designers, writers, and developers who've helped 350+ DTC brands boost conversions through web, email, and landing page optimization.
If you want a sneak peak of what your site or email could look like optimized, you may grab a free audit where we'll analyze your site/email, show you redesign samples, and give you an actionable roadmap. Or book a strategy call with our founders for a live site review, all 100% free.
Otherwise, enjoy the read and steal what works for your brand.
Company
Lull Mattress operates in one of the most saturated direct-to-consumer categories imaginable, but here's what matters for your strategy: they're a perfect example of a brand that refused to blend into the "sleep better" noise that dominates their space. Like every company in a crowded market, they could have copied successful competitors or stuck with their existing messaging, but instead they chose to test fundamentally different positioning angles to find their unique conversion sweet spot. Sound familiar? Every marketing leader in competitive categories faces this challenge: you know your product works, but you're not sure which story about it will make people actually buy.
Psychological Drivers
For context, we're a team of top strategists, designers, writers, and developers who've helped 350+ DTC brands boost conversions through web, email, and landing page optimization.
If you want a sneak peak of what your site or email could look like optimized, you may grab a free audit where we'll analyze your site/email, show you redesign samples, and give you an actionable roadmap. Or book a strategy call with our founders for a live site review, all 100% free.
Otherwise, enjoy the read and steal what works for your brand.
Company
Lull Mattress operates in one of the most saturated direct-to-consumer categories imaginable, but here's what matters for your strategy: they're a perfect example of a brand that refused to blend into the "sleep better" noise that dominates their space. Like every company in a crowded market, they could have copied successful competitors or stuck with their existing messaging, but instead they chose to test fundamentally different positioning angles to find their unique conversion sweet spot. Sound familiar? Every marketing leader in competitive categories faces this challenge: you know your product works, but you're not sure which story about it will make people actually buy.
Get A Free Website Audit.
We’ll identify what’s leaking revenue on your site and show you how to fix it. The free audit includes:
Conversion Barriers
For context, we're a team of top strategists, designers, writers, and developers who've helped 350+ DTC brands boost conversions through web, email, and landing page optimization.
If you want a sneak peak of what your site or email could look like optimized, you may grab a free audit where we'll analyze your site/email, show you redesign samples, and give you an actionable roadmap. Or book a strategy call with our founders for a live site review, all 100% free.
Otherwise, enjoy the read and steal what works for your brand.
Company
Lull Mattress operates in one of the most saturated direct-to-consumer categories imaginable, but here's what matters for your strategy: they're a perfect example of a brand that refused to blend into the "sleep better" noise that dominates their space. Like every company in a crowded market, they could have copied successful competitors or stuck with their existing messaging, but instead they chose to test fundamentally different positioning angles to find their unique conversion sweet spot. Sound familiar? Every marketing leader in competitive categories faces this challenge: you know your product works, but you're not sure which story about it will make people actually buy.
How To Structure
For context, we're a team of top strategists, designers, writers, and developers who've helped 350+ DTC brands boost conversions through web, email, and landing page optimization.
If you want a sneak peak of what your site or email could look like optimized, you may grab a free audit where we'll analyze your site/email, show you redesign samples, and give you an actionable roadmap. Or book a strategy call with our founders for a live site review, all 100% free.
Otherwise, enjoy the read and steal what works for your brand.
Company
Lull Mattress operates in one of the most saturated direct-to-consumer categories imaginable, but here's what matters for your strategy: they're a perfect example of a brand that refused to blend into the "sleep better" noise that dominates their space. Like every company in a crowded market, they could have copied successful competitors or stuck with their existing messaging, but instead they chose to test fundamentally different positioning angles to find their unique conversion sweet spot. Sound familiar? Every marketing leader in competitive categories faces this challenge: you know your product works, but you're not sure which story about it will make people actually buy.
Your brand story is powerful, but when real customers validate it, it becomes even more compelling. A generic review section won't reinforce your brand's unique attributes as effectively as a curated one.
In today's market, people don't just buy products—they buy into brands. Your About Us page isn't just a background story; it's a critical touchpoint for shaping how users perceive your brand.
A wall of text won't capture attention or communicate your brand effectively. If your About Us page isn't visually engaging, you're missing a key opportunity to leave a lasting impression.
Customers love knowing the "why" behind a product. If they understand the problem you set out to solve and the journey of creating it, they're more likely to feel connected to your brand.
A strong mission statement gives customers a reason to believe in your brand beyond just the products you sell. If your mission isn't clearly communicated, you miss an opportunity to create deeper connections.
Customers don't just buy products—they buy into stories. A compelling brand story helps differentiate you from competitors and creates a deeper connection with your audience.
Customers want to know what they can expect from your brand consistently. A strong brand promise sets clear expectations and reassures users that they're making the right choice.
Consumers want to support brands that align with their beliefs. If your values aren't clearly stated, you miss the chance to connect with like-minded customers who care about more than just the product.
People don't just buy products—they buy into stories. A faceless brand feels transactional, but a compelling founder story makes your business more relatable and memorable.